The Heart of the Matter assignment

DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

1. How relevant is the setting to the action of The Heart of the Matter? How do the climate, the war, and the indigenous people of this remote colonial outpost affect Scobie, Louise, Helen, and Wilson? Is the novel implicitly or explicitly anticolonial?
2. Scobie thinks that “no human being can really understand another, and no one can arrange another’s happiness” (p. 75). What are the fateful consequences of Scobie’s trying to make others happy? In what ways does the novel reveal the limits of our ability to understand one another?
3. What kind of woman is Louise? Why is her love of literature so often regarded with derision in the novel? Why is she so upset when Scobie is passed over for the commissionership? To what extent is she responsible for Scobie’s downfall?
4. What role does Yusef play in the novel? By what means does he entice Scobie into a corrupt relationship? Are we meant to see him as a diabolical character or merely as someone working the colonial occupation to his best advantage?
5. In discussing mercy and damnation, Father Rank says, “The Church knows all the rules. But it doesn’t know what goes on in a single human heart” (p. 254). To what extent can The Heart of the Matter be read as a critique of the Catholic Church? In what ways does the novel show the workings of the human heart to be beyond the comprehension of Catholic doctrine?
6. Early in the novel, Scobie promises to find a way to send Louise to South Africa, and we read that “He would still have made the promise even if he could have foreseen all that would come of it” (p. 50). What are the consequences of this promise? Why would Scobie still have made it, even if he could foresee the ruin that it would cause?
7. In what ways is Wilson a foil for Scobie? How are the two men different? For what reasons does Wilson wish to destroy Scobie?
8. How has the death of his only child affected Scobie and the decisions he makes throughout the novel?
9. Why is Scobie so drawn to Helen? Why do they feel so “safe” in each other’s presence? Why does this sense of safety turn out to be so dangerous?
10. In what ways do the subplots of spying and diamond smuggling parallel the novel’s central concern with relationships? In what ways is the novel about the tensions between openness and secrecy, honesty and deception?
11. At the end of the novel, Father Rank says of Scobie, “It may seem an odd thing to say—when a man’s as wrong as he was—but I think, from what I saw of him, that he really loved God.” To which Louise replies: “He certainly loved no one else” (p. 255). Are these statements about Scobie true? Does he love God and no one else? If so, how can we explain the choices he has made—to commit adultery and finally suicide?
12. After Pemberton’s suicide, Scobie thinks: “Suicide was for ever out of his power—he couldn’t condemn himself for eternity—no cause was important enough” (p. 83). Why does Scobie kill himself, even when he believes it will bring eternal damnation? How does he rationalize his suicide to himself? Should his suicide be considered self-sacrifice for the well-being of Helen and Louise? Is suicide his only choice? What else might he have done?